Showing posts with label witchy finger cookies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label witchy finger cookies. Show all posts

Thursday, October 31, 2013

Making Witch Finger Cookies




I've seen this one posted on Pinterest so many times. But these are the best instructions I've found. It took a couple of tries to get the right thickness and look.

I used store bought sugar cookie dough, added 1 cup of flour (you can use less or add a little at a time), then knead. If the cookie dough gets too dry, add 1/2 tsp of water (or enough to make it pliable). You don't want to put too much water unless it gets mushy.

After that, roll dough into a ball, then into a long coil. This helps make two/three fingers at a time. If the dough continues to fall apart, dip your fingers in some water, roll the coil into a ball again, and then roll into a coil. Think of it as working with clay. If it gets a little dry, just add some water. Press dough to flatten slightly if that is the desired look. Score with a knife, place the almond slices at the tip and press in place. Bake according to instructions.


First Test Batch - Made them too thick.
I just told the kids they were monster finger cookies.
Before - dusting/contouring with cocoa powder
After - dusting/contouring with cocoa powder

I made seven different sizes/thickness to test out. Then from there, I chose which size/thickness I'd use. I really liked how they turned out. Let the cookies cool down before dusting/contouring with cocoa powder.